• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • News
  • Features
  • Opinion
  • Arts & Fashion
  • Photography
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • Cainte
  • Sports
  • Archives
    • Volume 24: 2022-23
    • Volume 23: 2021-22
    • Volume 22: 2020-21
    • Volume 21: 2019-20
    • Volume 20: 2018-19
    • Volume 19: 2017-18
    • Volume 18: 2016-17
    • Volume 17: 2015-16
    • Volume 16: 2014-15
    • Volume 15: 2013-14
    • Volume 14: 2012-13
    • Volume 13: 2011-12
  • About
    • Get Involved
    • Contact Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy

Student Independent News

NUI Galway Student Newspaper

Gender-based heckling at Glasgow University mars debate

March 12, 2013 By SIN Staff

An article recently appeared in The Guardian, reporting on incidents of gender-based heckling. Liam King gives his opinion on the matter…

The University of Glasgow: where misogyny is to be expected?
The University of Glasgow: where misogyny is to be expected?

The Guardian recently reported that during a prestigious debating competition at Glasgow University, two participants, Rebecca Meredith and Marlena Valles, were heckled on the basis of their appearance, specifically, due to their being women.

Upon complaining, they were informed that this was ‘to be expected’ and ‘par for the course’ for female participants. I don’t believe I need to explain that this is unacceptable behaviour in 2013. According to that article, it pervades every facet of college life, from the gym to the library. That such attitudes can still exist with such ubiquity at this point in time is genuinely appalling. And it seems they still do, despite some perceptions to the contrary.

Rebecca herself states that she has been contacted by multiple people in the wake of the incident with stories of their being victims of misogyny, including those who have abandoned debating in light of this, with comments about how wearing a shorter skirt may help in winning debates, or to defer to their male partner because “men are more convincing.”

The incident at the GUU has since resulted in a number of societies disassociating from the union, a rally containing up to 400 protesters, and a petition approaching 4,000 signatures at the time of writing calling for the expulsion of the alleged perpetrators.  The Union President has apologised, stating that such incidents are “entirely incompatible with our values”, while the Cambridge Union has pledged to no longer send debaters to the competition until the matter is addressed

There will always be those with distasteful opinions in corners of the internet, but open derision of someone at an on-campus event solely on grounds of their gender cannot be tolerated in modern times. Multiple human rights documents have stressed that discrimination on the basis of gender is a breach of a fundamental right.

So how do we rate for avoidance of sexism here at NUI Galway? I’ve attended several different societies and sports clubs in my time here, and have very rarely encountered it, at least in situations lacking quite a lot of alcohol, and rarely even then.

Our own Lit&Deb Society, which I’ve attended several times, occasionally echoes with shouts of “RESIGN!” whenever a member of the committee takes the stand, but I don’t remember a single misogynistic comment, and if one did arise I can’t imagine it passing unchallenged.

I’ve attended film screenings on campus, and when something less than politically correct came up from a dated film, it was usually greeted with jeers and laughter rather than a positive response. While I wouldn’t try to say that these attitudes are entirely absent from NUI Galway, they don’t seem to permeate college life here in the same way as was described in The Guardian’s article.

Possibly we have not entirely achieved parity — in the most recent Students’ Union elections, the overwhelming majority of the candidates were male. But so far as I’m aware, the criteria for candidates involves twenty signatures, filling out a form by a certain date, and the willingness to run a campaign, which I don’t believe constitutes a deliberate barrier to women.

This seems a far cry from a campus in which heckling on grounds of gender is “to be expected” as a matter of course. And it seems that this is set to change, with Cambridge Union stating its refusal to send further debaters until the incident is resolved with an apology and steps taken towards gender equality in the university. The message must be sent that gender based heckling is no longer acceptable in today’s world.

Do you think female students are treated equally to male students here in NUI Galway?

Lead image via Wikimedia Commons
Enhanced by Zemanta
SIN Staff
+ posts
  • SIN Staff
    https://sin.ie/author/sin-admin-2/
    Vice President – Welfare and Equality Officer Candidate: Izzy Tiernan
  • SIN Staff
    https://sin.ie/author/sin-admin-2/
    Leas Uachtarán don Ghaeilge Candidate: Faye Ní Dhomhnaill
  • SIN Staff
    https://sin.ie/author/sin-admin-2/
    Leas Uachtarán don Ghaeilge Candidate: Seánie Ó Gáibhín
  • SIN Staff
    https://sin.ie/author/sin-admin-2/
    Student Speak

Related

Filed Under: Opinion Tagged With: Cambridge Union Society, Glasgow, Glasgow University, Glasgow University Union, Guardian, National University of Ireland Galway, NUI Galway Students' Union, Wikimedia Commons

Reader Interactions

Primary Sidebar

Read our latest issue:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 SIN Student Newspaper. All rights reserved.

 

Loading Comments...